Critique, The other lost art
Journal Entry: Thu Mar 13, 2008, 4:30 PM
I've just about had it with some of the frigging stoopid comments people leave. I'm about ready to disable comments on stuff. I always enable critiques, so I can read your responses and valid critique. What irritates the crappouttame is these type of comments:
This isn't art in my eyes.
This picture says nothing.
If you don't do (what I want) your work is a waste of time.
I don't like it - stop doing these.
I don't like that color.
I hate (insert car make here).
Seriously, what the phuck is any artist supposed to take away from this commentary? OOOOhhh sorry, next time we'll run it past you first to see if it's "art", or if you approve? Ideally critique, is supposed to provide the artist with suggestions to improve the work. Drawing something you like doesn't make it "better" in anyone's eye but yours. Telling someone their art is a waste of time is not just a little bit offensive to any artist. If you don't like it, fine. Lots of people might not like some of your stuff either, but they keep their opinions to themselves, because their opinion of your expression doesn't matter.
Artists don't create art for anyone other than themselves and their clientele. Whether you like the color they picked matters not. Your opinion of what constitutes art, matters not. Whether the art "speaks" to you, impresses you or thrills you doesn't matter either.
If you like it, fine - tell them why. If you don't, either provide a meaningful, mature critique or explaination. If all you have to add is "this is ugly to me" then consider your self pre-advised to STFU.
- Mood:
Irritated
Devious Comments
--
I reserve the right to be entirely wrong.
Well said, Russ
--
--== The Snowman ==--
Owner of The Skinventory [link]
Wizop @ Wincustomize.com
Admin @ Skinz.org
Member of visionLeague
Medlem af *denmark
Former Admin @ Skinbase.org
cheers mate
--
Check out my gallery>>> [link]
cheers mate
--
Check out my gallery>>> [link]
--
The world hold hope for dreamers, and lovers. I am neither of those.
In the words of a good friend of mine... "There's this girl I like... but... well... She lives in heaven... and I live in hell..."
--
Nobody told me!
Jess
--
People are like stained-glass windows. They sparkle and shine when the sun is out; but when the darkness sets in their true beauty is revealed only if there is a light inside.-Elisabeth Kubler-Ross
Admin of *PhotographersClub
Find Me In: #devart
I say, make like a duck and let the stupid stuff roll right off your back. You can probably recognize them before finishing the second sentence (assuming they can actually write in sentences)--just stop and go on to the next one.
Or, take the advice from Elvis Costello that I've taken for years: I used to be disgusted; now I try to be amused.
--
[link] This is Awesome!
That IS critique. Just because it's not positive doesn't mean it doesn't have something more behind it.
Aside from that, despite people not getting serious comments, be glad you get some, hundreds of thousands struggle to be seen. Ignore the people you don't like.
--
The Young Artist
Previous Page12345... Next Page